Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Nurisso, Marco, Fernando, Jesseba, Deshpande, Raj, Perotti, Alan, Marjieh, Raja, Frankland, Steven M., Lewis, Richard L., Webb, Taylor W., Campbell, Declan, Vaccarino, Francesco, Cohen, Jonathan D., Petri, Giovanni
Format: Preprint
Published: 2025
Subjects:
Online Access:https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.14797
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
Table of Contents:
  • Intelligent systems must deploy internal representations that are simultaneously structured -- to support broad generalization -- and selective -- to preserve input identity. We expose a fundamental limit on this tradeoff. For any model whose representational similarity between inputs decays with finite semantic resolution $\varepsilon$, we derive closed-form expressions that pin its probability of correct generalization $p_S$ and identification $p_I$ to a universal Pareto front independent of input space geometry. Extending the analysis to noisy, heterogeneous spaces and to $n>2$ inputs predicts a sharp $1/n$ collapse of multi-input processing capacity and a non-monotonic optimum for $p_S$. A minimal ReLU network trained end-to-end reproduces these laws: during learning a resolution boundary self-organizes and empirical $(p_S,p_I)$ trajectories closely follow theoretical curves for linearly decaying similarity. Finally, we demonstrate that the same limits persist in two markedly more complex settings -- a convolutional neural network and state-of-the-art vision-language models -- confirming that finite-resolution similarity is a fundamental emergent informational constraint, not merely a toy-model artifact. Together, these results provide an exact theory of the generalization-identification trade-off and clarify how semantic resolution shapes the representational capacity of deep networks and brains alike.