Transportability of Prognostic Markers: Rethinking Common Practices through a Sufficient-Component-Cause Perspective
Fuente:
arXiv
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Preprint |
| Published: |
2025
|
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1866915641666043904 |
|---|---|
| author | Sadatsafavi, Mohsen Pereira, Gavin Chen, Wenjia |
| author_facet | Sadatsafavi, Mohsen Pereira, Gavin Chen, Wenjia |
| contents | Transportability, the ability to maintain performance across populations, is a desirable property of markers of clinical outcomes. However, empirical findings indicate that markers often exhibit varying performances across populations. For prognostic markers that are advertised as predictive risk equations, oftentimes a form of updating is required when the equation is transported to populations with different disease prevalences. Here, we revisit transportability of prognostic markers through the lens of the foundational framework of sufficient component causes (SCC). We argue that transporting a marker 'as is' implicitly assumes predictive values are transportable, whereas conventional prevalence adjustment shifts the locus of transportability to accuracy metrics (sensitivity and specificity). Using a minimalist SCC framework that decomposes risk prediction into its causal constituents, we show that both approaches rely on strong assumptions about the stability of cause distributions. A SCC framework instead invites making transparent assumptions about how different causes vary across populations, leading to different transportation methods. For example, in the absence of any external information other than disease prevalence, a cause-neutral perspective can assume all causes are responsible for change in prevalence, leading to a new form of marker transportation. Numerical experiments demonstrate that different transportability assumptions lead to varying degrees of information loss, depending on the distribution of causes. A SCC perspective challenges common assumptions and practices for marker transportability, and proposes transportation algorithms that reflect our knowledge or assumptions about how causes vary across populations. |
| format | Preprint |
| id |
arxiv_https___arxiv_org_abs_2511_04065 |
| institution | arXiv |
| publishDate | 2025 |
| record_format | arxiv |
| spellingShingle | Transportability of Prognostic Markers: Rethinking Common Practices through a Sufficient-Component-Cause Perspective Sadatsafavi, Mohsen Pereira, Gavin Chen, Wenjia Applications Transportability, the ability to maintain performance across populations, is a desirable property of markers of clinical outcomes. However, empirical findings indicate that markers often exhibit varying performances across populations. For prognostic markers that are advertised as predictive risk equations, oftentimes a form of updating is required when the equation is transported to populations with different disease prevalences. Here, we revisit transportability of prognostic markers through the lens of the foundational framework of sufficient component causes (SCC). We argue that transporting a marker 'as is' implicitly assumes predictive values are transportable, whereas conventional prevalence adjustment shifts the locus of transportability to accuracy metrics (sensitivity and specificity). Using a minimalist SCC framework that decomposes risk prediction into its causal constituents, we show that both approaches rely on strong assumptions about the stability of cause distributions. A SCC framework instead invites making transparent assumptions about how different causes vary across populations, leading to different transportation methods. For example, in the absence of any external information other than disease prevalence, a cause-neutral perspective can assume all causes are responsible for change in prevalence, leading to a new form of marker transportation. Numerical experiments demonstrate that different transportability assumptions lead to varying degrees of information loss, depending on the distribution of causes. A SCC perspective challenges common assumptions and practices for marker transportability, and proposes transportation algorithms that reflect our knowledge or assumptions about how causes vary across populations. |
| title | Transportability of Prognostic Markers: Rethinking Common Practices through a Sufficient-Component-Cause Perspective |
| topic | Applications |
| url | https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.04065 |