K-Way Energy Probes for Metacognition Reduce to Softmax in Discriminative Predictive Coding Networks
Fuente:
arXiv
Enregistré dans:
| Auteur principal: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Preprint |
| Publié: |
2026
|
| Sujets: | |
| Accès en ligne: | |
| Tags: |
Ajouter un tag
Pas de tags, Soyez le premier à ajouter un tag!
|
| _version_ | 1866908957947199488 |
|---|---|
| author | Cacioli, Jon-Paul |
| author_facet | Cacioli, Jon-Paul |
| contents | We present this as a negative result with an explanatory mechanism, not as a formal upper bound.
Predictive coding networks (PCNs) admit a K-way energy probe in which each candidate class is fixed as a target, inference is run to settling, and the per-hypothesis settled energies are compared. The probe appears to read a richer signal source than softmax, since the per-hypothesis energy depends on the entire generative chain.
We argue this appearance is misleading under the standard Pinchetti-style discriminative PC formulation. We present an approximate reduction showing that with target-clamped CE-energy training and effectively-feedforward latent dynamics, the K-way energy margin decomposes into a monotone function of the log-softmax margin plus a residual that is not trained to correlate with correctness. The decomposition predicts that the structural probe should track softmax from below.
We test this across six conditions on CIFAR-10: extended deterministic training, direct measurement of latent movement during inference, a post-hoc decoder fairness control on a backpropagation network, a matched-budget PC vs BP comparison, a five-point Langevin temperature sweep, and trajectory-integrated MCPC training. In every condition the probe sat below softmax. The gap was stable across training procedures within the discriminative PC family. Final-state and trajectory-integrated training produced probes whose AUROC_2 values differed by less than 10^-3 at deterministic evaluation.
The empirical regime is small: single seed, 2.1M-parameter network, 1280 test images. We frame the result as a preprint inviting replication. We discuss conditions under which the decomposition does not apply (bidirectional PC, prospective configuration, generative PC, non-CE energy formulations) and directions for productive structural probing the analysis does not foreclose. |
| format | Preprint |
| id |
arxiv_https___arxiv_org_abs_2604_11011 |
| institution | arXiv |
| publishDate | 2026 |
| record_format | arxiv |
| spellingShingle | K-Way Energy Probes for Metacognition Reduce to Softmax in Discriminative Predictive Coding Networks Cacioli, Jon-Paul Machine Learning Computation and Language Neural and Evolutionary Computing I.2.6; I.5.1 We present this as a negative result with an explanatory mechanism, not as a formal upper bound. Predictive coding networks (PCNs) admit a K-way energy probe in which each candidate class is fixed as a target, inference is run to settling, and the per-hypothesis settled energies are compared. The probe appears to read a richer signal source than softmax, since the per-hypothesis energy depends on the entire generative chain. We argue this appearance is misleading under the standard Pinchetti-style discriminative PC formulation. We present an approximate reduction showing that with target-clamped CE-energy training and effectively-feedforward latent dynamics, the K-way energy margin decomposes into a monotone function of the log-softmax margin plus a residual that is not trained to correlate with correctness. The decomposition predicts that the structural probe should track softmax from below. We test this across six conditions on CIFAR-10: extended deterministic training, direct measurement of latent movement during inference, a post-hoc decoder fairness control on a backpropagation network, a matched-budget PC vs BP comparison, a five-point Langevin temperature sweep, and trajectory-integrated MCPC training. In every condition the probe sat below softmax. The gap was stable across training procedures within the discriminative PC family. Final-state and trajectory-integrated training produced probes whose AUROC_2 values differed by less than 10^-3 at deterministic evaluation. The empirical regime is small: single seed, 2.1M-parameter network, 1280 test images. We frame the result as a preprint inviting replication. We discuss conditions under which the decomposition does not apply (bidirectional PC, prospective configuration, generative PC, non-CE energy formulations) and directions for productive structural probing the analysis does not foreclose. |
| title | K-Way Energy Probes for Metacognition Reduce to Softmax in Discriminative Predictive Coding Networks |
| topic | Machine Learning Computation and Language Neural and Evolutionary Computing I.2.6; I.5.1 |
| url | https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.11011 |