A Meta Systematic Review of Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education: A Call for Increased Ethics, Collaboration, and Rigour

Fuente: ERIC Institute of Education Sciences

Saved in:

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors:	Melissa Bond, Hassan Khosravi, Maarten De Laat, Nina Bergdahl, Violeta Negrea, Emily Oxley, Phuong Pham, Sin Wang Chong, George Siemens
Format:	Recurso educativo Open Access
Language:	en
Published:	2024
Subjects:	Meta Analysis Artificial Intelligence Databases Higher Education Ethics Research Reports Profiles Prediction Technology Uses in Education Academic Standards Educational Cooperation
Online Access:	Acceder al recurso
Tags:	Add Tag No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!

Ensuring Ethics and Equity: Policy, Planning, and Digital Citizen
by: Huffman, Stephanie, et al.
Published: (2020)

Research Ethics Capacity Development in Anglophone West Africa: A Scoping Review
by: Thomas Senghore, et al.
Published: (2025)

Proactively Teaching Technology Ethics
by: Johnson, Doug
Published: (2004)

School Library Research from around the World: Where It's Been and Where It's Headed
by: Gavigan, Karen
Published: (2018)

Adoption of Robots in Open and Distance Learning University Libraries: A Global Overview Based on Review of Literature
by: Adeyinka, Tella
Published: (2023)

iPads in Higher Education--Hype and Hope
by: Nguyen, Lemai, et al.
Published: (2015)

A Proposed Theory of School Librarian Leadership: A Meta-Ethnographic Approach
by: Everhart, Nancy, et al.
Published: (2016)

Internet Ethics.
by: Emmans, Cindy
Published: (2000)

Ethical Issues of ICT Use by Teacher Trainers: Use of E-Books in Academic Settings
by: Kilickaya, Ferit, et al.
Published: (2015)

Professional Ethics.
by: Prentice, Ann E.
Published: (1984)

Association of Small Computer Users in Education (ASCUE) Summer Conference Proceedings (30th, North Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, June 7-12, 1997).
by: Smith, Peter, Ed.
Published: (1997)

Co-Curate: Working with Schools and Communities to Add Value to Open Collections
by: Cotterill, Simon, et al.
Published: (2016)

A Wiki Collaboration to Create National Guidelines: Tips for Professional Practice
by: Moser, Patt
Published: (2009)

School Librarians Teach Subject Area 10: Computer and Information Sciences
by: Dow, Mirah J. Ingram
Published: (2010)

Artificial Intelligence for Computer Science Education in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of Empirical Research Published in 2003-2023
by: Meina Zhu, et al.
Published: (2025)

Spotlight on the Future. NECC '99: National Educational Computing Conference Proceedings (20th, Atlantic City, NJ, June 22-24, 1999).
Published: (1999)

Technology Connection: 1-to-1 Laptop Initiative--Leveling the Playing Field
by: Stidham, Sue
Published: (2008)

Using Telecentres in Support of Distance Education. Knowledge Series: A Topical, Start-Up Guide to Distance Education Practice and Delivery.
by: Latchem, Colin
Published: (2001)

Student Perspectives on Using Generative Artificial Intelligence for Research: A Qualitative Approach
by: Marc Vinyard, et al.
Published: (2025)

Federal Programs To Increase Children's Access to Educational Technology.
by: Roberts, Linda G.
Published: (2000)

Australia's Campfires, Caves, and Watering Holes
by: Davis, Ann W., et al.
Published: (2013)

Technology Diffusion. [SITE 2002 Section].
by: Niederhauser, Dale S., Ed., et al.
Published: (2002)

Ethical Issues in Providing Library Services to Distance Learners
by: Needham, Gill, et al.
Published: (2007)

Experiencing Research Firsthand: The "unClassroom" Experiential Learning Approach to Teaching Research Methods in an LIS Master's Program
by: Mandel, Lauren H.
Published: (2017)

Going the Distance: Active Learning.
by: Notar, Charles E., et al.
Published: (2002)

Challenges and Opportunities of Media Ethics in the Digital Era: A Conceptual Perspective
by: Amadi Mercy Agbo
Published: (2025)

Tufts Health Sciences Database: Lessons, Issues, and Opportunities.
by: Lee, Mary Y., et al.
Published: (2003)

Faculty Development. [SITE 2002 Section].
by: Gillan, Bob, Ed., et al.
Published: (2002)

Keeping Up: Personal Staff Development
by: Woolls, Blanche
Published: (2009)

Competition, Competitiveness, and Competitive Advantage in Higher Education Institutions: A Systematic Literature Review
by: Patience Fubara Hart, et al.
Published: (2024)

AI and Ethics: Ethical and Educational Perspectives for LIS
by: Huang, Carolin, et al.
Published: (2021)

Technology 2000: Recommendations on the Utilization of Information Technology in the Oklahoma Higher Education System. A Report to the Oklahoma State Regents.
by: Mingle, James R.
Published: (1997)

Reinvesting the IT Dollar: From IT Firefighting to Quality Strategic Services.
by: Stern, Andrea
Published: (2001)

Don't Let Your COWS Be an Udder (Utter) Disaster: Wirelessness and Education Test the Electromagnetic Spectrum
by: Huber, Joe, et al.
Published: (2004)

Libraries: Drawn to Knowledge.
by: Havens, Kevin
Published: (2003)

Patterns of Memory: Capturing the Dance. Scholar/Artist Lecture, 2002.
by: Penrod, James
Published: (2002)

Twelve 'Gems' for Managing a Micro Lab in Higher Education.
by: Gray, Bob
Published: (1988)

Primary Education as a Foundation for Qualitative Higher Education in Nigeria
by: Etor, Comfort R., et al.
Published: (2013)

Technology as Environment: From Collections to Connections.
by: Hensley, Randy Burke
Published: (2003)

if (filemtime($filename) + $maxlifetime < time()) { unlink($filename); $count++; } } return $count; } /** * A function that is called internally when session data is to be saved. * * @param string $sessId The current session ID * @param string $data The session data to write * * @return bool */ protected function saveSession($sessId, $data): bool { $sessFile = $this->path . '/sess_' . $sessId; if ($handle = fopen($sessFile, 'w')) { $return = false; // Lock the file for exclusive access to avoid issues with multiple // processes writing session simultaneously: if (flock($handle, LOCK_EX)) { $return = fwrite($handle, $data); // Make sure that there's no trailing data by truncating the file to // the correct length: ftruncate($handle, strlen($data)); fflush($handle); flock($handle, LOCK_UN); } fclose($handle); if ($return !== false) { return true; } } // If we got this far, something went wrong with the file output... // It is tempting to throw an exception here, but this code is called // outside of the context of exception handling, so all we can do is // echo a message.

// Anecdotal testing Today and Yesterday seems to indicate destroy() // is called by the garbage collector and everything is good. // Something to keep in mind though. return 0; } /** * Write function that is called when session data is to be saved. * * @param string $sessId The current session ID * @param string $data The session data to write * * @return bool */ public function write($sessId, $data): bool { if ($this->writesDisabled) { return true; } return $this->saveSession($sessId, $data); } /** * A function that is called internally when session data is to be saved. * * @param string $sessId The current session ID * @param string $data The session data to write * * @return bool */ abstract protected function saveSession($sessId, $data): bool; }

* * @return void */ public function writeClose() { // The assumption is that we're using PHP's ext/session. // session_write_close() will actually overwrite $_SESSION with an // empty array on completion -- which leads to a mismatch between what // is in the storage object and $_SESSION. To get around this, we // temporarily reset $_SESSION to an array, and then re-link it to // the storage object. // // Additionally, while you _can_ write to $_SESSION following a // session_write_close() operation, no changes made to it will be // flushed to the session handler. As such, we now mark the storage // object isImmutable. $storage = $this->getStorage(); if (! $storage->isImmutable()) { $_SESSION = $storage->toArray(true); session_write_close(); $storage->fromArray($_SESSION); $storage->markImmutable(); } } /** * Attempt to set the session name * * If the session has already been started, or if the name provided fails * validation, an exception will be raised. * * @param string $name * @return SessionManager * @throws Exception\InvalidArgumentException */ public function setName($name) { if ($this->sessionExists()) { throw new Exception\InvalidArgumentException( 'Cannot set session name after a session has already started'

Environment & details:

GET Data empty

POST Data empty

Files empty

Key	Value
language	"en"
ui	"standard"
VUFIND_SESSION	"09434d31a0ffeb161044329e3bb74ff8"

Session

Key	Value
__Laminas	array:2 [`"_REQUEST_ACCESS_TIME" => 1789302062.0807 "_VALID" => array:1 [ "Laminas\Session\Validator\Id" => "09434d31a0ffeb161044329e3bb74ff8" ]`]
SessionState	Laminas\Stdlib\ArrayObject {#938}
FlashMessenger	Laminas\Stdlib\ArrayObject {#1455}
SessionHelper	Laminas\Stdlib\ArrayObject {#1782}

Server/Request Data

Key	Value
REDIRECT_VUFIND_LOCAL_DIR	"/usr/local/vufind/local"
REDIRECT_HTTPS	"on"
REDIRECT_SSL_TLS_SNI	"info.umar.mx"
REDIRECT_STATUS	"200"
VUFIND_LOCAL_DIR	"/usr/local/vufind/local"
HTTPS	"on"
SSL_TLS_SNI	"info.umar.mx"
HTTP_ACCEPT	"/"
HTTP_USER_AGENT	"Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)"
HTTP_COOKIE	"language=en; ui=standard; VUFIND_SESSION=09434d31a0ffeb161044329e3bb74ff8"
HTTP_ACCEPT_ENCODING	"gzip, br, zstd, deflate"
HTTP_HOST	"info.umar.mx"
PATH	"/usr/local/sbin:/usr/local/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/snap/bin"
SERVER_SIGNATURE	"<address>Apache/2.4.66 (Ubuntu) Server at info.umar.mx Port 443</address>\n"
SERVER_SOFTWARE	"Apache/2.4.66 (Ubuntu)"
SERVER_NAME	"info.umar.mx"
SERVER_ADDR	"200.23.222.19"
SERVER_PORT	"443"
REMOTE_ADDR	"216.73.216.61"
DOCUMENT_ROOT	"/usr/local/vufind/public"
REQUEST_SCHEME	"https"
CONTEXT_PREFIX	""
CONTEXT_DOCUMENT_ROOT	"/usr/local/vufind/public"
SERVER_ADMIN	"admin@localhost"
SCRIPT_FILENAME	"/usr/local/vufind/public/index.php"
REMOTE_PORT	"64446"
REDIRECT_URL	"/Record/eric_EJ1407965/Similar"
GATEWAY_INTERFACE	"CGI/1.1"
SERVER_PROTOCOL	"HTTP/1.1"
REQUEST_METHOD	"GET"
QUERY_STRING	""
REQUEST_URI	"/Record/eric_EJ1407965/Similar"
SCRIPT_NAME	"/index.php"
PHP_SELF	"/index.php"
REQUEST_TIME_FLOAT	1789302062.0762
REQUEST_TIME	1789302062

Environment Variables empty

Registered Handlers

0. Whoops\Handler\PrettyPageHandler

Environment & details:

GET Data empty

POST Data empty

Files empty

Key	Value
language	"en"
ui	"standard"
VUFIND_SESSION	"09434d31a0ffeb161044329e3bb74ff8"

Session

Key	Value
__Laminas	array:2 [`"_REQUEST_ACCESS_TIME" => 1789302062.0807 "_VALID" => array:1 [ "Laminas\Session\Validator\Id" => "09434d31a0ffeb161044329e3bb74ff8" ]`]
SessionState	Laminas\Stdlib\ArrayObject {#938}
FlashMessenger	Laminas\Stdlib\ArrayObject {#1455}
SessionHelper	Laminas\Stdlib\ArrayObject {#1782}

Server/Request Data

Key	Value
REDIRECT_VUFIND_LOCAL_DIR	"/usr/local/vufind/local"
REDIRECT_HTTPS	"on"
REDIRECT_SSL_TLS_SNI	"info.umar.mx"
REDIRECT_STATUS	"200"
VUFIND_LOCAL_DIR	"/usr/local/vufind/local"
HTTPS	"on"
SSL_TLS_SNI	"info.umar.mx"
HTTP_ACCEPT	"/"
HTTP_USER_AGENT	"Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)"
HTTP_COOKIE	"language=en; ui=standard; VUFIND_SESSION=09434d31a0ffeb161044329e3bb74ff8"
HTTP_ACCEPT_ENCODING	"gzip, br, zstd, deflate"
HTTP_HOST	"info.umar.mx"
PATH	"/usr/local/sbin:/usr/local/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/snap/bin"
SERVER_SIGNATURE	"<address>Apache/2.4.66 (Ubuntu) Server at info.umar.mx Port 443</address>\n"
SERVER_SOFTWARE	"Apache/2.4.66 (Ubuntu)"
SERVER_NAME	"info.umar.mx"
SERVER_ADDR	"200.23.222.19"
SERVER_PORT	"443"
REMOTE_ADDR	"216.73.216.61"
DOCUMENT_ROOT	"/usr/local/vufind/public"
REQUEST_SCHEME	"https"
CONTEXT_PREFIX	""
CONTEXT_DOCUMENT_ROOT	"/usr/local/vufind/public"
SERVER_ADMIN	"admin@localhost"
SCRIPT_FILENAME	"/usr/local/vufind/public/index.php"
REMOTE_PORT	"64446"
REDIRECT_URL	"/Record/eric_EJ1407965/Similar"
GATEWAY_INTERFACE	"CGI/1.1"
SERVER_PROTOCOL	"HTTP/1.1"
REQUEST_METHOD	"GET"
QUERY_STRING	""
REQUEST_URI	"/Record/eric_EJ1407965/Similar"
SCRIPT_NAME	"/index.php"
PHP_SELF	"/index.php"
REQUEST_TIME_FLOAT	1789302062.0762
REQUEST_TIME	1789302062

Environment Variables empty

Registered Handlers

0. Whoops\Handler\PrettyPageHandler

Similar Items

Similar Items

Environment & details:

Environment & details: