Clinician Diagnostic Ratings and Countertransference Reactions Towards Grandiose and Vulnerable Narcissism
Fuente:
Wiley Open Access
Saved in:
| Main Authors: | , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Artículo Open Access |
| Published: |
Wiley
2025
|
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| _version_ | 1867009191737032704 |
|---|---|
| author | Nicholas J. S. Day Marko Biberdzic Ava Green Georgia Denmeade Bo Bach Brin F. S. Grenyer |
| author_facet | Nicholas J. S. Day Marko Biberdzic Ava Green Georgia Denmeade Bo Bach Brin F. S. Grenyer Nicholas J. S. Day Marko Biberdzic Ava Green Georgia Denmeade Bo Bach Brin F. S. Grenyer |
| collection | Wiley Open Access |
| contents | Clinician Diagnostic Ratings and Countertransference Reactions Towards Grandiose and Vulnerable Narcissism Nicholas J. S. Day Marko Biberdzic Ava Green Georgia Denmeade Bo Bach Brin F. S. Grenyer Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy ABSTRACTBackgroundNarcissistic personality disorder (NPD) is known to comprise two distinct but connected phenotypes related to ‘grandiosity’ and ‘vulnerability’, respectively. While evidence suggests differing countertransference responses to narcissism subtype expression, no study has examined this using a qualitative methodology and explored associations with ratings of personality disorder severity.MethodMental health clinicians (N = 180, 67% female, age = 38.9), completed qualitative clinical reflections and ratings of overall personality disorder severity towards two hypothetical vignettes displaying pathological narcissism (‘grandiose’ and ‘vulnerable’ narcissism respectively), as well as a rating of attitudes towards patients in their routine practice who resemble these vignettes.ResultsDistinct qualitative themes were identified between narcissistic subtype, with grandiose narcissism evoking anger, lack of empathy and hopelessness, compared to sympathy, sadness and discomfort in vulnerable narcissism. In terms of diagnostic category, the grandiose vignette was predominately identified as ‘narcissistic personality disorder’ (97%), whereas the vulnerable vignette was a mixture of ‘depressive disorder’ (29%), ‘narcissistic personality disorder’ (24%), ‘trauma and stressor related disorders’ (21%) and ‘borderline personality disorder’ (21%). Attitude scores differed significantly between subtypes, with more negative attitudes towards narcissistic grandiosity than narcissistic vulnerability. The grandiose vignette was also rated as displaying more overall personality impairment, with an association observed between negative clinician attitude scores and increased ratings of personality disorder severity.DiscussionTwo potential pathways are outlined to interpret these findings. The first is that inordinate stigma towards narcissistic grandiosity negatively biases clinicians when working with these patients due to feelings of anger and frustration. The second is that clinicians are drawn to minimise pathology of vulnerable patients due to their feelings of sadness and empathy. We propose that effective diagnosis and psychotherapy for pathological narcissism rely on clinicians' ability to balance these two dilemmas and resist either extreme. 10.1002/cpp.70070 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| doi_str_mv | 10.1002/cpp.70070 |
| format | Artículo Open Access |
| id | wiley_oa_10_1002_cpp_70070 |
| institution | Wiley Open Access |
| license_str_mv | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| publishDate | 2025 |
| publisher | Wiley |
| record_format | wiley_oa |
| spellingShingle | Clinician Diagnostic Ratings and Countertransference Reactions Towards Grandiose and Vulnerable Narcissism Nicholas J. S. Day Marko Biberdzic Ava Green Georgia Denmeade Bo Bach Brin F. S. Grenyer Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy Clinician Diagnostic Ratings and Countertransference Reactions Towards Grandiose and Vulnerable Narcissism Nicholas J. S. Day Marko Biberdzic Ava Green Georgia Denmeade Bo Bach Brin F. S. Grenyer Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy ABSTRACTBackgroundNarcissistic personality disorder (NPD) is known to comprise two distinct but connected phenotypes related to ‘grandiosity’ and ‘vulnerability’, respectively. While evidence suggests differing countertransference responses to narcissism subtype expression, no study has examined this using a qualitative methodology and explored associations with ratings of personality disorder severity.MethodMental health clinicians (N = 180, 67% female, age = 38.9), completed qualitative clinical reflections and ratings of overall personality disorder severity towards two hypothetical vignettes displaying pathological narcissism (‘grandiose’ and ‘vulnerable’ narcissism respectively), as well as a rating of attitudes towards patients in their routine practice who resemble these vignettes.ResultsDistinct qualitative themes were identified between narcissistic subtype, with grandiose narcissism evoking anger, lack of empathy and hopelessness, compared to sympathy, sadness and discomfort in vulnerable narcissism. In terms of diagnostic category, the grandiose vignette was predominately identified as ‘narcissistic personality disorder’ (97%), whereas the vulnerable vignette was a mixture of ‘depressive disorder’ (29%), ‘narcissistic personality disorder’ (24%), ‘trauma and stressor related disorders’ (21%) and ‘borderline personality disorder’ (21%). Attitude scores differed significantly between subtypes, with more negative attitudes towards narcissistic grandiosity than narcissistic vulnerability. The grandiose vignette was also rated as displaying more overall personality impairment, with an association observed between negative clinician attitude scores and increased ratings of personality disorder severity.DiscussionTwo potential pathways are outlined to interpret these findings. The first is that inordinate stigma towards narcissistic grandiosity negatively biases clinicians when working with these patients due to feelings of anger and frustration. The second is that clinicians are drawn to minimise pathology of vulnerable patients due to their feelings of sadness and empathy. We propose that effective diagnosis and psychotherapy for pathological narcissism rely on clinicians' ability to balance these two dilemmas and resist either extreme. 10.1002/cpp.70070 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| title | Clinician Diagnostic Ratings and Countertransference Reactions Towards Grandiose and Vulnerable Narcissism |
| topic | Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy |
| url | https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/cpp.70070 |